Odisha News, Odisha Latest news, Odisha Daily - OrissaPOST
  • Home
  • Trending
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Feature
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • More..
    • Odisha Special
    • Editorial
    • Opinion
    • Careers
    • Sci-Tech
    • Timeout
    • Horoscope
    • Today’s Pic
  • Video
  • Epaper
  • News in Odia
  • Home
  • Trending
  • State
  • Metro
  • National
  • International
  • Business
  • Feature
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • More..
    • Odisha Special
    • Editorial
    • Opinion
    • Careers
    • Sci-Tech
    • Timeout
    • Horoscope
    • Today’s Pic
  • Video
  • Epaper
  • News in Odia
No Result
View All Result
OrissaPOST - Odisha Latest news, English Daily -
No Result
View All Result

Reckless, Relentless

PNN
Updated: September 3rd, 2023, 09:35 IST
in Edit
0
Aakar Patel
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsAppShare on Linkedin

I have a novel out this month, and also an event that discusses the role of fiction writing in engaging with the material world. The lawyers who represented Rahul Gandhi in his case in Surat have also just published a work of fiction titled “Theory of Suspicion.” Kirit Panwala and Rohan Panwala (they also represent me in a similar case in Surat filed by the same BJP legislator) draw on their experience as lawyers practising on the criminal side to tell a story. The core of the book is a multiple murder mystery and the authors say that they draw their inspiration from an actual series of events.

Their novel is unusual because in India few professionals write books and even fewer write fiction centred around their area of expertise. On my shelves, I can see a couple of autobiographies by two Pakistan chief justices, MC Chagla’s Roses in December and MC Setalvad’s memoirs but there is not much else from those in the legal profession. For this reason, we must be grateful to the authors who, woven into their murder mystery, give us insights into how the police functions, what the protocols of State are with respect to the judiciary, the conduct of lawyers and some tips for handling interrogation. For these alone, the book is worth reading.

Also Read

Iran's private message to Israel: ‘Can intervene if military campaign continues in Gaza’

Mid East Great Again

5 days ago

Nameless Doctrine

6 days ago

I wanted however to discuss another aspect outside of the mystery that the Panwalas take up and that is regarding jurisprudence and innovation. They start and build their story around a judge who develops a theory that discards what we call common law and begins to adjudicate cases on whim. In brief, his theory may be described as suspicion being the same as guilt and then this finding of “guilt” followed swiftly by punishment. This reflects in many ways the view of large parts of our nation in these times.

The modern criminal justice system is designed around the rights of the accused because the power in a criminal case is overwhelmingly with the State. The government controls the police, it has a veto on the appointment and transfer of judges, it conducts prosecutions and carries out incarcerations. The accused has little power or agency in comparison and for this reason democracies construct their justice system around the rights of those the State goes after.

This will surprise those, likely the majority of the population, who think it should be centred around the State’s ability to punish bad people. Such a sentiment is common even among those who are or have been part of the State. In 2007, the fifth report of the Administrative Reforms Commission on public order opens with this quotation from APJ Abdul Kalam. “If real criminals in our society are left without punishment for years, because of delay in criminal justice for various reasons, it will indeed result in the multiplication of people taking to criminal acts.” This is of a piece with those who demand the death penalty and hangings on the assumption that State violence against ‘real criminals’ produces a just society.

This attitude, this mindset is the reason why independent India has tightened laws to give more power to the State against defendants, and either not undone colonial-era laws or made them even harsher. The massacre at Jallianwala Bagh came after a gathering that protested the Rowlatt Act, which gave the government sweeping powers of detention without trial. Few might know that the law was never applied and was in fact rescinded. But in every state of India today there are laws worse than the Rowlatt Act and people are jailed without trial and even without crime, under laws that allow preventive detention.

Has this harshness resulted been effective in curbing crime? The numbers produced by the Union government say no. The conviction rate in IPC cases was 64.8 per cent in 1961. In 2005 it was 42.4 per cent. The 2017 National Crime Record Bureau data shows that for murder the conviction rate is 43 per cent in India. For rape it is 32 per cent, for kidnapping 26 per cent, for injury including acid attacks 29 per cent and for rioting 20 per cent. Harsher laws have not in fact resulted in what the former President Kalam wanted.

The acquittals have another story to tell. Criminal law has the power to destroy lives and its use for this reason must be guarded, measured and calibrated, not recklessly and relentlessly applied as is the case unfortunately in our nation. These are the thoughts one has when reading the Panwalas’ story about the judge and his family. Their judge is fictional but he has real life parallels when it comes to going rogue. Consider, to give one example, how many judges in the lower judiciary “overturn” judgements and explicit Supreme Court directives when it comes to arrests and the application of such charges as sedition, when there is no call or incitement to violence. It is in the middle of this reality that this novel has been written. Without revealing much I should say that the judge in the novel gets his comeuppance in more ways than one. For this reason to me the book was satisfying.

By Aakar Patel

Tags: Aakar PatelOP Editorial
ShareTweetSendShare
Suggest A Correction

Enter your email to get our daily news in your inbox.

IEC (1yr.)

 

OrissaPOST epaper Sunday POST OrissaPOST epaper

Click Here: Plastic Free Odisha

slide 2 to 4 of 30
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Ramakanta Sahoo

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Bijswajit Pradhan

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Rajashree Pravati Mohanty

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Smitarani Sahoo

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Jyotshna Mayee Pattnaik

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Priyabrata Mohanty

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Aishwarya Ranjan Mohanty

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Surya Sidhant Rath

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Ramakanta Sahoo

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Priyasha Pradhan

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Manas Samanta

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Ankita Balabantray

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Anshuman Sahoo

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Nishikant Rout

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Tapaswini Mallick

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Sisirkumar Maharana

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Subhajyoti Mohanty

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Archit Mohapatra

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Chinmay Kumar Routray

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Anasuya Sahoo

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Amritansh Mishra

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Pitabas Tripathy

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

D Rama Rao

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Adyasha Priyadarsani Sendha

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Vandana Singh

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Archana Parida

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Geetanjali Patro

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Tabish Maaz

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Sitakanta Mohanty

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Aman Kumar Barisal

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Ramakanta Sahoo

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Bijswajit Pradhan

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Rajashree Pravati Mohanty

December 12, 2019
#MyPaperBagChallenge

Smitarani Sahoo

December 12, 2019

Archives

Select Month

    Editorial

    Trouble For Iran

    Iran flag
    June 18, 2025

    The escalating conflict between Israel and Iran has plunged the Middle East into deeper turmoil, with ramifications stretching far beyond...

    Read more

    Korean Challenge

    Lee Jae-myung
    June 17, 2025

    The people of South Korea have shown their maturity as votaries of democracy by recently gifting a landslide victory to...

    Read more

    Mid East Great Again

    Iran's private message to Israel: ‘Can intervene if military campaign continues in Gaza’
    June 16, 2025

    For decades, current Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been warning about the “existential threat” that a nuclear-armed Iran poses...

    Read more

    Nameless Doctrine

    June 15, 2025

    On 12 June, the United Nations General Assembly adopted a resolution demanding an immediate, unconditional and lasting ceasefire in Gaza....

    Read more
    • Home
    • State
    • Metro
    • National
    • International
    • Business
    • Editorial
    • Opinion
    • Sports
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Jobs
    Developed By Ratna Technology

    © 2024 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST

    • News in Odia
    • Orissa POST Epaper
    • Video
    • Home
    • Trending
    • Metro
    • State
    • Odisha Special
    • National
    • International
    • Sports
    • Business
    • Editorial
    • Entertainment
    • Horoscope
    • Careers
    • Feature
    • Today’s Pic
    • Opinion
    • Sci-Tech
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Jobs

    © 2024 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST

      • News in Odia
      • Orissa POST Epaper
      • Video
      • Home
      • Trending
      • Metro
      • State
      • Odisha Special
      • National
      • International
      • Sports
      • Business
      • Editorial
      • Entertainment
      • Horoscope
      • Careers
      • Feature
      • Today’s Pic
      • Opinion
      • Sci-Tech
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Jobs

      © 2024 All rights Reserved by OrissaPOST